What I'm thinking on immigration...
I've only heard/read secondhand accounts of the Congressional immigration legislation -- legislation I believe the Senate has since shot down -- but if true, I think it is an extremely bad idea to make it a felony to "deliver assistance" to illegal immigrants. (That is the term I heard quoted; laughable in its lack of legal clarity if accurate.)
Everything in my American and Christian upbringing is offended by that idea. Frankly, the discussions on kicking out 12 million people, or footing the bill to lock 1/2 that many up, making the head of a household (we usually call him Dad) leave every few years on a hope and a prayer he can come back, making it a felony to "deliver assistance" (?) (food? insulin?), fining illegal migrant workers some whopping percentage of their income, folks on bullhorns shouting "criminals!" at people they don't know jack about -- a lot of it goes against my moral grain... and its turning my tide to a more sweeping approach than I had previously assessed. Yes, we need to secure our borders, but we also have to remain Americans here. John made an Irish joke earlier... no sweat here... but we have treated our nation to much difficulty in the past when we backlashed against an immigrant group, whether Chinese or Irish or German or Peurto Rican. My grandparents immigrated here, now I'm like all-get-out-entitled.
This is a whopping issue... the more I consider it, the more complex it becomes. I sooo don't know the answers, but I am concerned the combination of heated emotions, election year posturing, polls, and knee jerk reactions will leave us on a course for tomorrow's civil rights movement. I've heard the arguments against amnesty, and don't outright reject them... but I do question if it would be better to deport criminals, and put working illegal families here on a track to citizenship that is forward oriented -- learning the language, laws, etc, not punative -- fines, harassment as a lumped sub-class in our society, etc. All Mexicans -- all Latinos -- whether legal or not, are being ensnared in this growing hostile environment. We're growing hostile to people as groups again. And we've become plumb insane when everyone repeats "jobs Americans won't do..." but never questions what the hey that says about Americans.
A couple weeks ago I thought the "new slavery" leftie stuff was over the top. But I've been thinking about it (ya'll will say mesmerized by the MSM)... we have some x million-odd people we're paying below minimum wages to, under constant threat of harassment by the law, thugs, whatever, with no recourse. Okay, yep, they volunteered to come here, and broke our laws doing it... not the same thing as the history of black slavery, but, you've still got Americans profiting off a sub-class of people. That's not right. And I know, kids are cutting school to protest, they're waving Mexican flags, etc. But, OTOH, they got an idea of how civil protest is done in America, the idea that in America their voice will matter (read: no carbombs, no flag burnings, loves and wants to be in America).
What is still missing from this debate is some of the problems at it's core: How do we farm our food without abusing a class of people -- whether legal or illegal migrant farm workers -- ? America was the world's bread basket... small farms were run by a family's wits and sweat and sold locally. Everybody from Leno to the Congress is commenting on what will happen to the price of peas. That's a problem. If Americans can't produce their own food sensibly without employing a shadow class at below legal pay rates, something more fundamental than documentation is wrong.